Labor & Employment Law Daily Wrap Up, TORT CLAIMS—D.S.C.: Employer failed to show documents taken by former employees were trade secrets, (Feb 3, 2025)
Law Firms Mentioned:Brewer Law Firm
Organizations Mentioned:Global Consulting USA LLC | Pinnacle Risk Engineering, LLC
By Patricia K. Ruiz, J.D.
The court found the employer’s description of its security measures to be vague and conclusory.
The U. S. District Court for the District of South Carolina denied a preliminary injunction to an employer seeking protection for alleged trade secrets under the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) and the South Carolina Trade Secrets Act (SCTSA). The court found the employer failed to make a clear showing that it took reasonable efforts to maintain the secrecy of the documents, and, thus, the documents were not protectable as trade secrets (Global Consulting USA LLC v. Pinnacle Risk Engineering, LLC, No. 2:24-cv-04919-DCN (D.S.C. Jan. 29, 2025)).
Background. Global Consulting USA LLC d/b/a Paragon Risk Engineering (Paragon) provides engineering and consulting work for clients. The defendants, Duane Yost and Tiffany Hrycyna were previously employed by Paragon, with the employment relationship ending June 3, 2024. Paragon alleged in its lawsuit that, in May 2024, its operations manager received a customer inquiry related to one of Yost’s projects. Because Yost was on vacation, the manager had permission to access Yost’s emails. The manager discovered documents and communications between Yost and one of Paragon’s clients. The manager contacted Yost, who informed him that he, Hrycyna, and another employee were planning on starting Pinnacle Risk Engineering, Inc., as a new company to compete with Paragon. Shortly after, the three employees resigned their employment with Paragon.
Subsequently, Paragon discovered the employees had been using Paragon resources to form their new company and had been soliciting Paragon’s clients. It also discovered that, in the days leading up to his resignation, Yost and Hrycyna downloaded proprietary and confidential Paragon technical guidance documentation, as well as proprietary and confidential Paragon pricing and client site information developed for Paragon clients.
Lawsuit. Paragon filed suit asserting nine causes of action: (1) breach of contract; (2) violation of the SCTSA; (3) tortious interference with contractual relations; (4) conversion; (5) breach of duty of loyalty; (6) civil conspiracy; (7) violation of the DTSA; (8) violation of the South Carolina Unfair Trade Practices Act (SCUTPA); and (9) unjust enrichment. Paragon moved for a preliminary injunction to prevent the defendants form using its alleged trade secrets and to restrain the defendants from soliciting or accepting business from Paragon’s clients about whom the trade secrets relate.
Motion for preliminary injunction. The court found that Paragon failed to demonstrate that it was likely to succeed on the merits and denied Paragon’s motion for preliminary injunction. The court reviewed the documents downloaded by the employees during their final days of employment and assumed without deciding that they contained the type of information courts usually protect as trade secrets. However, the court found Paragon failed to clearly show it had taken reasonable efforts to maintain the secrecy of the information in the documents, making only vague, if not conclusory, references to its security measures.
The court further found that Paragon’s employee handbook, which contains confidentiality provisions, was not a reasonable secrecy measure, as it has no place for an employee signature and because testimony suggested Paragon was not vigilant in enforcing the handbook or reminding its employees of the confidentiality provisions contained therein. Paragon failed to make a clear showing that it took reasonable efforts to maintain the secrecy of the documents, the court found. Thus, Paragon failed to show the documents merit protection as trade secrets.
The Case is No. 2:24-cv-04919-DCN.
Judge: Norton, D.
Attorneys: Connor Taylor Jasso for Global Consulting USA LLC. Amanda Davis McKendrick (Brewer Law Firm) for Pinnacle Risk Engineering, LLC.
Companies: Global Consulting USA LLC; Pinnacle Risk Engineering, LLC
Cases: TortClaims RemediesDamages StateLawClaims SouthCarolinaNews