Go to Wolters Kluwer VitalLaw.comGo to Wolters Kluwer VitalLaw.com
VitalLaw®
  • Find answers to your questions
  • Log in to access your subscriptions
In depth. On point.
In depth. On point.
  • Home
  • Legal Directory
  • Home
  • Legal Directory
In depth. On point.
  • Articles
  • Articles
  • Law Firms
  • Law Firms
  • Organizations
  • Organizations
    • COVERAGE, LIABILITY—6th Cir.: Employer intent required to incur liability for client’s harassment of an employee
    • COVERAGE, LIABILITY—M.D. Tenn.: Female truck driver sexually harassed by trainer can’t advance TVPA claim
    • DISCRIMINATION—DISABILITY—D. Kan.: EEOC gets trial on claims Walmart failed to accommodate two deaf overnight stockers
    • DISCRIMINATION—RELIGION—5th Cir.: Hospital worker briefly denied exemption to flu shot mandate forfeited appeal of lawsuit, divided panel rules
    • DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA NEWS—D.C. Attorney General issues business advisory regarding restaurant workers
    • EXPERT INSIGHTS—6 lessons from The Bear: What employers can learn from the workplace TV show
    • EXPERT INSIGHTS—Remote work compliance considerations for H-1B, E-3, and H-1B1 employees
    • LABOR NEWS—Teamsters secures settlement with UPS on outstanding grievances
    • LABOR—UNIONS, UNION MEMBERS—4th Cir.: Union member satisfied demand requirement in suit alleging officers’ fiduciary breach
    • LITIGATION NEWS, TRENDS—School district sues EEOC, cites worries that data is sought to ‘target’ district and employees
    • PROCEDURE—8th Cir.: Taxpayers can challenge school district’s practice of allowing teachers paid union leave
    • RETALIATION—7th Cir.: District court properly limited types of alleged adverse employment actions IDOT engineer could present at trial
    • WAGE-HOUR—D. Nev.: Sheepherder wage-fixing and market-allocation antitrust claims to proceed against Western Range Association and member ranches
  • Articles
  • Articles
  • Law Firms
  • Law Firms
  • Organizations
  • Organizations

    Labor & Employment Law Daily Wrap Up, PROCEDURE—8th Cir.: Taxpayers can challenge school district’s practice of allowing teachers paid union leave, (Aug 12, 2025)

    Law Firms Mentioned:American Federation of Teachers Local 7007 | Bredhoff & Kaiser | Squires, Waldspurger & Mace | Upper Midwest Law Center
    Organizations Mentioned:Bredhoff & Kaiser, PLLC | Independent School District No. 11 | Labor Relations | for Anoka Hennepin Education Minnesota, (American Federation of Teachers Local 7007

    By Ronald Miller, J.D.

    Because municipal taxpayers have a “direct and immediate” interest in municipal expenditures, they “may sue to enjoin an illegal use of the moneys of a municipal corporation.”

    School district residents had standing to sue a ...

    By Ronald Miller, J.D.

    Because municipal taxpayers have a “direct and immediate” interest in municipal expenditures, they “may sue to enjoin an illegal use of the moneys of a municipal corporation.”

    School district residents had standing to sue a school district and teachers’ union about a union leave and reimbursement plan, ruled the Eighth Circuit in a 2-1 decision, reversing the judgment of a district court. As municipal taxpayers, the residents have a “direct and immediate” interest in municipal expenditures, and so, “may sue to enjoin an illegal use of the moneys of a municipal corporation.” The injury central to municipal taxpayer standing is the “misuse” of public funds by the municipality. Here, the expenditure was solely occasioned by the activities complained of. Further, the residents met any traceability requirement, since their interest in school district expenditures was not diluted where the General Fund contained municipal, state, and federal funds. Judge Shepherd filed a separate dissenting opinion (Huizenga v. Independent School District No. 11, No. 21-2418 (8th Cir. Aug. 11, 2025)).

    Paid union leave. Three residents and taxpayers sued a school district and teachers’ union about their union leave and reimbursement plan, alleging constitutional and statutory violations. The union is the collective bargaining representative of teachers employed by the school district. Their agreement allows teachers to take paid union leave to work for the union. The union reimburses the school district’s costs for hiring substitutes, but not the (higher) pro rata cost of salaries and benefits for teachers on union leave.

    Disagreeing with the teachers’ alleged political and campaign advocacy during union leave, the residents sued the union and the school district under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging a violation of the Free Speech Clause. The residents also alleged violations of the Minnesota Constitution and the state Public Employee Labor Relations Act. The district court dismissed the case for lack of standing. The Eighth Circuit reversed and remanded. On remand, the district court granted summary judgment, dismissing the residents’ claims due to a lack of Article III standing. The residents appealed.

    Standing. For Article III standing, a plaintiff must have “(1) suffered an injury in fact, (2) that is fairly traceable to the challenged conduct of the defendant, and (3) that is likely to be redressed by a favorable judicial decision.” The injury in fact requires the plaintiff to show “‘an invasion of a legally protected interest’ that is ‘concrete and particularized’ and ‘actual or imminent.’”

    Municipal taxpayer standing. In general, the taxpayer’s interest “in seeing that Treasury funds are spent in accordance with the Constitution does not give rise to the kind of redressable ‘personal injury’ required for Article III standing.” Municipal taxpayer standing arises from the “peculiar” relationship of taxpayers to their municipality, like that “subsisting between stockholder and private corporation.” Because municipal taxpayers have a “direct and immediate” interest in municipal expenditures, they “may sue to enjoin an illegal use of the moneys of a municipal corporation.”

    To have municipal taxpayer standing, a plaintiff (1) “must actually be a taxpayer of the municipality that she wishes to sue” and (2) “must establish that the municipality has spent tax revenues on the allegedly illegal action.”

    “Misuse” of public funds. The residents must establish they are taxpayers of the municipality they are suing. In this instance, two of the three residents are municipal taxpayers of the district. The third moved out of the district. They belong to a particular “taxpayer base” of district residents with a special “interest in the funds allocated to” the school district. The injury central to municipal taxpayer standing is the “misuse” of public funds by the municipality. An injunction against future misuse remedies the injury.

    The residents must establish that the district spends tax revenues on the activities complained of. The union leave policy causes a direct expenditure of district funds, giving residents a direct interest as taxpayers. The residents meet the injury in fact requirement for Article III standing.

    Good-faith pocketbook action. For state taxpayer standing, the Eighth Circuit has defined “a good-faith pocketbook action” as “an injury to the taxpayer’s ‘direct and particular financial interest.’” To the extent that the “good-faith pocketbook action” requirement applies to municipal taxpayer standing, the requirement for taxpayers to show a “direct and particular financial interest” applies only so far as the taxpayer’s interest is defined in Frothingham v. Mellon, 262 U.S. 447 (1923). The Supreme Court there held that the “interest of a taxpayer of a municipality in the application of its moneys is direct and immediate.”

    First Amendment rights. Here, the residents argued that the leave agreement forces municipal taxpayers to subsidize a union’s political speech in violation of their First Amendment rights. The school district makes an expenditure when it pays substitute teachers while full-time teachers take paid union leave to engage in political and campaign advocacy. The expenditure is solely occasioned by the activities complained of. Even though the union reimburses the cost of the substitute teacher, the residents have a “direct pecuniary injury” because their taxes directly support the activities complained of.

    Traceable element. Next, the union argued that municipal taxpayer standing requires a “fairly traceable” element, that the residents show their municipal taxpayer dollars are uniquely implicated. Because teacher salaries are paid from the school district’s General Fund, which intermingles state, federal and local funds, the union contended that the residents cannot show that the expenditures from the union leave policy are “uniquely attributable” to local tax dollars.

    However, the appeals court concluded that the residents’ direct and immediate interest in school district expenditures was not diluted where the General Fund contains municipal, state, and federal funds. Municipal taxpayer standing allows taxpayers to challenge the misuse of municipal funds. Intermingled funds are still “resources that reflect [the taxpayer’s] contributions.” Thus, the residents met any traceability requirement.

    Accordingly, the residents met their burden of establishing Article III standing. They are municipal taxpayers of the school district, and they showed an expenditure of school district funds occasioned solely by the activities complained of.

    The judgment of the district court was reversed, and the case remanded for further proceedings.

    Dissent. In dissent, Judge Shepherd took the view that the resident taxpayers failed to “show that the [district] has actually expended funds on the allegedly illegal elements of the disputed practice.” Under the subsidy theory, the district is essentially offering the union a discounted rate on its teachers, but it is not expending or appropriating money for union activities. Next, the dissent would find that the majority erred in rejecting the requirement of a “direct dollars-and-cents injury,” and in disregarding the disconnect between the expenditure and the allegedly illegal action. Thus, the dissent would hold that the residents lacked standing and affirm the district court.

    The case is No. 21-2418.

    Judge: Benton, W.

    Attorneys: Austin M. Lysy (Upper Midwest Law Center) for Don Huizenga, Nancy Powell and Jim Bendtsen. Kristin C. Nierengarten (Squires, Waldspurger & Mace) for Independent School District No. 11. Faaris Akremi (Bredhoff & Kaiser) for Anoka Hennepin Education Minnesota, (American Federation of Teachers Local 7007).

    Companies: Independent School District No. 11; for Anoka Hennepin Education Minnesota, (American Federation of Teachers Local 7007

    Cases: Procedure IndividualRights EmployeeLeave Labor UnionsMembers ContractClaims ArkansasNews IowaNews MinnesotaNews MissouriNews NebraskaNews NorthDakotaNews SouthDakotaNews GCNNews

    © 2026 CCH Incorporated and its affiliates and licensors. All rights reserved.

    • Manage Cookie Preferences
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Use