Go to Wolters Kluwer VitalLaw.comGo to Wolters Kluwer VitalLaw.com
VitalLaw®
  • Find answers to your questions
  • Log in to access your subscriptions
In depth. On point.
In depth. On point.
  • Home
  • Legal Directory
  • Home
  • Legal Directory
In depth. On point.
  • Articles
  • Articles
  • Law Firms
  • Law Firms
  • Organizations
  • Organizations
    • REMEDIES, DAMAGES—D. Md.: Termination of thousands of federal probationary employees stayed
    • AGENCY NEWS—Rubio declares foreign policy actions of federal agencies exempt from APA notice-and-comment requirements
    • DISCRIMINATION—RACE—N.D. Ala.: White male’s claims against 3M fail due to invalid comparators, dearth of discriminatory-intent evidence
    • DISCRIMINATION—RELIGIOUS—E. D. Wash.: Discrimination claims brought by state employee who refused COVID vaccine fail to survive summary judgment
    • EMPLOYEE STATUS—M.D. Tenn.: Lack of standing dooms freelance writers’ challenge to DOL’s 2024 Rule on independent contractor status
    • EXPERT INSIGHTS—Ninth Circuit Affirms Heightened Make-Whole Remedies in Unfair Labor Practice Charges
    • EXPERT INSIGHTS—Title VII Compliance Amidst DEI Executive Orders and Criminal Investigation Threats
    • LABOR NEWS—UAW, citing tariff concerns, brings ULP charges against Volkswagen in Chattanooga dispute
    • LABOR—ARBITRATION—7th Cir.: Employer loses dispute over whether employees’ loss of hours was result of ‘Act of God’
    • LITIGATION NEWS, TRENDS—Judge Alsup orders administration to offer reinstatement to fired federal probationary employees
    • LITIGATION NEWS, TRENDS—States sue McMahon, Trump over Education Department RIFs
    • RETALIATION—1st Cir.: Radiologist can’t revive claims she was forced to resign, discriminated against, due to complaints about colleague
    • RETALIATION—E.D. Mich.: Qui tam FCA and AKS claims fail for poor specificity, some retaliation claims survive
    • STATE-LAW CLAIMS—S.D. Cal.: Employer’s attempt to recoup payments for military leave did not constitute unlawful discrimination
    • WHITE HOUSE NEWS—Court temporarily blocks parts of Trump executive order against Perkins Coie
    • WORTH NOTING—Cases of note dealing with arbitration issues
  • Articles
  • Articles
  • Law Firms
  • Law Firms
  • Organizations
  • Organizations

    Labor & Employment Law Daily Wrap Up, EXPERT INSIGHTS—Ninth Circuit Affirms Heightened Make-Whole Remedies in Unfair Labor Practice Charges, (Mar 14, 2025)

    Organizations Mentioned:Kronick Moskovitz Tiedemann & Girard | Labor Relations | Macy's, Inc. | Thryv

    By Alec D. Tyra and Vance Piggott of Kronick Moskovitz Tiedemann & Girard

    On January 21, 2025, the Ninth Circuit United States Court of Appeals determined the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB” or “Board”) did not abuse its discretion by expanding its monetary remedies. This 2-1 ruling uphel ...

    By Alec D. Tyra and Vance Piggott of Kronick Moskovitz Tiedemann & Girard

    On January 21, 2025, the Ninth Circuit United States Court of Appeals determined the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB” or “Board”) did not abuse its discretion by expanding its monetary remedies. This 2-1 ruling upheld an order by the NLRB requiring Macy’s (“the Company”) to provide expanded “make-whole” remedies to workers who experienced unfair labor practices. Notably, this Ninth Circuit decision creates a split among the United States Court of Appeals regarding remedies available to the NLRB, which increases the likelihood of a Supreme Court review in the future.

    Background

    After months of failed negotiations regarding a successor collective bargaining agreement, Union members rejected a final offer from Macy’s proposing terms related to wages and pensions. Subsequently, the Union went on strike from September 4, 2020, to December 4, 2020. In December 2020, the Union rejected an additional offer from Macy’s and notified the Company that it was making “an unconditional offer to return our members to work immediately.” In response, the Company asked the Union members not to return to work, which ultimately led to a dispute regarding the Company’s lockout of Union members. The Union filed its original unfair practice charge against Macy’s in December 2020 (later amended to February 2021), alleging unfair labor practices when it locked out Union members. On February 11, 2021, the NLRB filed its complaint asserting the Company violated Section 8(a)(1) and 8(a)(3) of the National Labor Relations Act (“NLRA”).

    The Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”) ruled against Macy’s, concluding the Company did violate the NLRA since it did not provide the Union “with a timely, clear, or complete offer, which set[s] forth the conditions necessary to avoid the lockout.” The ALJ then suggested remedies that would make the Union whole, including “any losses of pay and benefits that they may have suffered by reason of the lockout,” including “search-for-work and interim employment expenses, regardless of whether those expenses exceed interim earnings.” The NLRB affirmed the ALJ’s ruling with two modifications; most significantly, the NLRB amended the “make-whole” remedy ordering that Macy’s “shall also compensate the employees for any other direct or foreseeable pecuniary harms incurred as a result of the unlawful lockout, including reasonable search-for-work and interim employment expenses, if any, regardless of whether these expenses exceed interim earnings.”

    NLRB has Authority for Heightened Remedies Pursuant to Thryv v. NLRB

    The Ninth Circuit agreed with the remedies issued by the NLRB, ordering the enforcement of the “make-whole” remedies for the Union members. This decision highlighted that “[t]he Board’s discretion in selecting remedies is exceedingly broad, and [the Court] will enforce a remedy unless it represents a clear abuse of discretion.” (referencing National Labor Relations Board v. Ampersand Publishing, LLC (Ninth Cir. 2022) 43 F.4th 1233.) Because the Court found no clear abuse of discretion, it deferred to the Board’s order for remedies.

    In doing so, the Ninth Circuit upheld the NLRB’s make whole remedy standard established in Thryv, Inc. (2022) 372 NLRB No. 22. In Thryv, the NLRB found that the respondent company violated Sections 8(a)(1) and (5) of the NLRA, and as a remedial measure, ordered “the respondent [to] compensate affected employees for all direct or foreseeable pecuniary harms suffered as a result of the respondent’s unfair labor practice.” The Fifth Circuit later vacated the Board’s remedies against Thryv because it found unfair labor practices did not occur. (Thryv, Incorporated v. National Labor Relations Board (Fifth Cir. 2024) 102 F.4th 727 (“Thryv”).) Though skeptical, the Fifth Circuit did not vacate the portion of the Thryv decision outlining the NLRB’s “make-whole” remedy standard.

    In Macy’s, the Ninth Circuit found that following the Thryv standard of “direct or foreseeable pecuniary harms” allows the Union members to be restored to the position they would be in, but for the occurrence of the unlawful lockout. Accordingly, the Ninth Circuit determined the NLRB’s Order is aligned with the purpose of making an employee whole and promoting industrial peace.

    Moving Forward

    This Ninth Circuit court ruling is significant in that it disagrees with a Third Circuit United States Court of Appeals decision, creating a split in the two circuits. In the 2024 decision, the Third Circuit declined to apply the Thryv “make-whole” standard. In National Labor Relations Board v. Starbucks Corporation (3d Cir. 2024) 125 F.4th 78, the Third Circuit held the expanded remedies did exceed the NLRB's authority under the NLRA as consequential damage orders. The Third Circuit explained broad consequential damage orders are beyond remedial since they improperly exceed the amount the employer unlawfully withheld.

    In addition, the Fifth Circuit United States Court of Appeals vacated portions of Thryv when it held the employer did not partake in unfair labor practices. The Fifth Circuit, however, did not rule against the Board’s authority to impose heightened “make-whole” remedies, though the court noted that the heightened standard was “a novel, consequential-damages-like labor law remedy.”

    The varying treatments by the Third, Fifth, and Ninth Circuit Courts could cause varying results among the other Circuits in the Court of Appeals and potentially create a situation requiring review from the Supreme Court. Also notable, the current administration has made changes regarding the composition of the NLRB. Given the changes in the Board, the Thryv standard could get revised or revisited by the NLRB and result in a change in law. Kronick will continue to follow developments on this new law and will update this legal alert as those developments warrant.

    Originally published February 6, 2025

    The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

    Alec D. Tyra

    Vance Piggott

    Kronick Moskovitz Tiedemann & Girard

    1331 Garden Hwy, 2nd Floor

    Sacramento, CA 95833 United States

    Tel.: +1 916 321 4500E-mail:

    URL: www.kmtg.com/

    © Mondaq Ltd., 2025 - Tel. +44 (0)20 8544 8300 - http://www.mondaq.com

    Attorneys: Alec D. Tyra and Vance Piggott (Kronick Moskovitz Tiedemann & Girard).

    ExpertInsights: Labor UnfairLaborPractices RemediesDamages LaborNews

    © 2026 CCH Incorporated and its affiliates and licensors. All rights reserved.

    • Manage Cookie Preferences
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Use