Go to Wolters Kluwer VitalLaw.comGo to Wolters Kluwer VitalLaw.com
VitalLaw®
  • Find answers to your questions
  • Log in to access your subscriptions
In depth. On point.
In depth. On point.
  • Home
  • Legal Directory
  • Home
  • Legal Directory
In depth. On point.
  • Articles
  • Articles
  • Law Firms
  • Law Firms
  • Organizations
  • Organizations
    • REMEDIES, DAMAGES—U.S.: Supreme Court holds off on request to vacate TRO in Special Counsel case
    • AGENCY NEWS—Federal employees receive ‘absurd weekend email’ requiring them to reveal what they have been working on
    • DISCHARGE—W.D. Ky.: Employer didn’t violate ADA or gun-rights law by firing worker who said he should ‘end it’ while holding gun in his car
    • DISCRIMINATION—AGE—D. Ariz.: Applicant who did not follow up with recruiter fails to advance claim
    • DISCRIMINATION—DISABILITY—4th Cir.: Worker fired for failing to disclose back surgeries at pre-hire exam, not because of disability
    • EXPERT INSIGHTS—Navigating the executive order ending affirmative action and DEI for federal contractors: essential steps for compliance
    • EXPERT INSIGHTS—Rescission of NLRB General Counsel memos on non-compete agreements indicates shift in enforcement priorities
    • LABOR PULSE—A Philadelphia labor leader calls out Trump’s course to the unitary executive
    • LITIGATION NEWS, TRENDS—Associated Press sues White House officials, seeks TRO and injunction
    • LITIGATION NEWS, TRENDS—DOGE overstepping bounds with SSA data, new lawsuit alleges
    • LITIGATION NEWS, TRENDS—New lawsuit filed relating to DOGE secrecy
    • PUBLIC EMPLOYEES—D.D.C.: USAID workers, placed on administrative leave by Trump administration, denied preliminary injunction
    • REMEDIES, DAMAGES—D. Md.: Government preliminarily enjoined from enforcing challenged provisions in two DEI-related EOs
  • Articles
  • Articles
  • Law Firms
  • Law Firms
  • Organizations
  • Organizations

    Labor & Employment Law Daily Wrap Up, DISCRIMINATION—DISABILITY—4th Cir.: Worker fired for failing to disclose back surgeries at pre-hire exam, not because of disability, (Feb 24, 2025)

    Law Firms Mentioned:Dinsmore & Shohl | Glazer Saad Anderson L.C.
    Organizations Mentioned:Dinsmore & Shohl, LLP | ND Fairmont LLC | ND Paper, LLC | ND Paper/Fairmont, LLC

    By Marjorie Johnson, J.D.

    The employee admitted that he was dishonest, “and dishonesty is misconduct worthy of termination, even if it is connected to a disability.”

    A paper product manufacturer did not violate the ADA by terminating a recently hired material han ...

    By Marjorie Johnson, J.D.

    The employee admitted that he was dishonest, “and dishonesty is misconduct worthy of termination, even if it is connected to a disability.”

    A paper product manufacturer did not violate the ADA by terminating a recently hired material handler for dishonesty after the HR manager discovered he lied during his pre-employment exam by stating that he “never” suffered from any back injuries or sought treatment for any conditions related to his back, but after several weeks on the job disclosed he had to miss work due to back spasms resulting from three back surgeries he underwent in the past two years. Because he admittedly lied during his physical and conceded that the employer cited that dishonesty as the reason for his termination, a jury could only reasonably infer that he was terminated because he was dishonest, the Fourth Circuit ruled in affirming summary judgment against him (Sigley v. ND Fairmont LLC, No. 23-2013 (4th Cir. Feb. 21, 2025)).

    Conditional job offer. On August 9, 2021, the employee applied for a material handler position with the employer, a paper product manufacturer. Because the job included physical requirements, such as “lifting, pushing, stooping, and standing for long periods of time,” the employer extended a job offer conditioned on the employee’s ability to pass a physical conducted by a third-party provider.

    Physical exam and paperwork. The employee completed his physical and accompanying paperwork on September 8. On the Informed Consent Checklist, he initialed the statement: “I understand that giving false, incomplete, incorrect or misleading information will be cause for termination of my employment.” He also completed the Health History Questionnaire and marked “Never” in response to two questions: (1) “Do you have a back fracture, strain, sprain, pain, stiffness, weakness, scoliosis, disc injury, disc rupture, arthritis or injury?” and (2) “Have you seen a chiropractor, doctor, or physical/occupational therapist for your back?”

    The clinician then signed the following statement: “I have discussed the medical questionnaire with the candidate and have informed the candidate that omitting or misrepresenting information on this form or with the therapist during this screening process, may be grounds for dismissal from employment.” The employee then reviewed the Questionnaire a second time, added his initials, and completed the remainder of the screening process.

    Discloses back surgeries. The employee passed his physical and began work on September 13. On October 28, he called out of work and told the HR manager, “I’m not getting any sleep for some reason and I don’t think I would be safe at all … I will be in tomorrow.” He met with her and the safety manager the next day and disclosed that he had undergone three back surgeries in the past two years and had a metal rod in his back. He explained that he sometimes experienced back spasms which were the “real reason” he missed work the day before. He added that he did not provide any information about his back injury during his physical.

    HR confers with the clinician. After the meeting, the HR manager contacted the third-party provider to confirm the employee’s statement that, as part of his post-offer exam, he had not disclosed any information and history relating to his back condition. The provider verified the omission and forwarded copies of his paperwork. As a result, the HR manager concluded that despite several clear warnings, the employee provided false, incorrect, and misleading information during his exam and terminated him because of that misconduct.

    Lawsuit. The employee filed this lawsuit alleging a single count of discriminatory discharge. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment, and in his motion the employee also discussed two unpled ADA claims: breach of confidentiality and failure to accommodate. The district court ultimately granted the employer’s motion, and this appeal followed.

    No inference of bias. Assuming without deciding that the employee could demonstrate the first three prongs of his prima facie case of disability bias, his claim failed at the fourth prong since he could not demonstrate that the circumstances of his discharge raised a reasonable inference of unlawful discrimination, concluded the Fourth Circuit. Instead, he admittedly lied about his back injury during his physical and conceded that the employer cited that dishonesty as the reason for his termination. Thus, a jury could only reasonably infer that he was terminated because he was dishonest.

    The appeals court squarely rejected his contention that his eventual disclosure of his disability prohibited the employer from firing him, citing a prior case in which it had explained that “[t]he ADA does not require an employer to simply ignore an employee’s blatant and persistent misconduct, even where that behavior is potentially tied to a medical condition.” Here, the employee admitted that he was dishonest, “and dishonesty is misconduct worthy of termination, even if it is connected to a disability.”

    No breach of confidentiality. The employee also argued that the employer violated §12112(d)(3)(B) by improperly accessing his confidential medical information to confirm his dishonesty. However, his complaint did not allege a breach of confidentiality claim and instead only contained a single count of disability discrimination under § 12112(a), which is a separate cause of action. Thus, because his confidentiality claim was untimely, the Fourth Circuit declined to address its merits. However, the court noted that he conceded that confidentiality was not at issue by admitting that the harm was not that the employer learned about the information, but that it terminated him based on the information itself.

    No failure to accommodate. His argument that the employer failed to accommodate his disability also failed on procedural grounds since he did not raise the separate claim in his complaint. But even if he did timely assert the claim, it still failed since in addition to conceding that he did not require an accommodation, he admitted that he never requested one.

    The case is No. 23-2013.

    Judge: Floyd, H.

    Attorneys: Hoyt Eric Glazer (Glazer Saad Anderson L.C.) for John Sigley. Kelby T. Gray (Dinsmore & Shohl) for ND Fairmont LLC a/k/a ND Paper, LLC and ND Paper/Fairmont, LLC.

    Companies: ND Fairmont LLC; ND Paper, LLC; ND Paper/Fairmont, LLC

    Cases: DisabilityDiscrimination Discrimination Discharge Procedure MarylandNews NorthCarolinaNews SouthCarolinaNews VirginiaNews WestVirginiaNews

    © 2026 CCH Incorporated and its affiliates and licensors. All rights reserved.

    • Manage Cookie Preferences
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Use