Labor & Employment Law Daily Wrap Up, DISCRIMINATION—AGE—S.D. Ohio: Employee’s late job application dooms discrimination claim, (Nov 13, 2025)
Law Firms Mentioned:Auman, Mahan & Furry | David M. Duwel & Associates
Organizations Mentioned:Dayton Lamina Corp.
By Nicholas Kaster, J.D.
That the employee applied less than six hours late was of no import and he cited no case law suggesting that the employer could not strictly enforce its deadline.
A federal district court in Ohio granted summary judgment to a production company employer in an employee’s age discrimination and retaliation claim where the employee’s job application was submitted after the deadline, albeit by less than six hours. The fact that the employer set forth a clear deadline, the employee applied late, and the employer uniformly applied that deadline across all job seekers meant that the employee never applied for the position. Thus, as a matter of law, not being selected for the position could not have been an adverse action. Accordingly, no prima facie case of discrimination could be shown. Moreover, since there was no evidence of any protected activity by the employee, much less any connection between said activity and an adverse action by the employer, the employee failed to set forth a prima facie case for retaliation (Moore v. Dayton Lamina Corp., No. 3:24-cv-207 (S.D. Ohio Nov. 6, 2025)).
The employee had been working in the employer’s processing department since 2006. In February 2023, the employer posted a job description for a product manager position. The description stated that all applicants had to submit their resumes to the company’s Vice President of Sales and Marketing “no later than” February 28, 2023.
Late application. The employee was working an overnight shift from February 28 to March 1 and emailed his resume to the Sales and Marketing VP at 5:52 a.m. on March 1. The VP refused to accept his late application and instead proceeded with the two timely applicants. The employer ended up hiring a candidate who was under the age of 40 at the time of the application.
The employee argued that the deadline was pretextual and illegitimate, as the VP would not have seen the resume before 8:00 a.m. on March 1, even if he had submitted it prior to midnight on February 28. He further asserted that he was otherwise qualified for the position. The employee also claimed that he was not told that the lateness of his application was the reason for his rejection until after he filed an age discrimination charge.
The employee filed suit, asserting claims of discrimination and retaliation in violation of the ADEA. The employer moved for summary judgment on both claims.
Age discrimination claim. As to the employee’s age discrimination claim, the employer argued that his late submission both made him unqualified for the position and meant that he never actually applied for the job, and thus, never suffered an adverse action. In support, the employer pointed to Hughes v. Youngstown St. Univ. in which the Tenth District Court of Appeals rejected an employee’s federal and state employment law claims, holding that, because the employee did not apply before the deadline, the employer not hiring him for the position could not have been an adverse employment action. The court found this holding to be on point.
In this case, the employer clearly stated an application deadline in the job posting and enforced that deadline as to all applicants, regardless of age. That the employee applied less than six hours late, rather than 13 days late as in the Hughes case, was of no import, said the court, and the employee cited no caselaw suggesting that the employer could not strictly enforce its deadline. Moreover, the employee conceded in his complaint that the VP told him two days prior to filing his OCRC charge that his untimely submission prevented him from being considered for the position. Thus, the employer’s enforcement of its application deadline could not have been a post hoc rationalization.
The fact that the employer set forth a clear deadline, the employee applied late, and the employer uniformly applied that deadline across all job seekers meant that the employee never applied for the Product Manager position, the court said. Thus, as a matter of law, not being selected for the position could not have been an adverse action. Moreover, since the successful candidate applied prior to the deadline, he was not a valid comparator.
Legitimate reason. Moreover, said the court, even if the employee had made a prima facie case, the employer easily met its burden of showing that its actual and uniform enforcement of its application deadline was a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for the purported adverse action of not hiring him. Thus, the burden would shift back to the employee to show evidence this proffered reason was mere pretext for the employer’s age-discriminatory intent.
The employer designated no such evidence. The job posting, the VP’s affidavit, and the email correspondence between the employee and the VP showed overwhelmingly that the employer’s proffered reason was based in fact and actually motivated the employer. It was undisputed that the VP was the sole decisionmaker, and that he did not know the employee, his interest in the position, or his past protected activity.
Finally, the employee’s protestations of "form over substance" were unsupported, and he cited no caselaw suggesting that a late application would be insufficient motivation for not hiring someone for a position. Consequently, the employee failed to demonstrate pretext. Thus, the court held that the employer was entitled to summary judgment on the age discrimination claim.
Retaliation claim. In his complaint, the employee alleged that he had filed several complaints of age discrimination for not being selected for promotional opportunities and that, as a result of his protected activity, the employer retaliated against him by not selecting him for the promotional opportunity.
At no point, however, did the employee specify what promotional opportunities he applied for; when he applied for them; why he was purportedly denied; what complaints of age discrimination he made; or when, where, and to whom he made them. Absent such information, the court could not consider any such complaints as protected activity.
Moreover, the employee’s OCRC charge could not be considered protected activity for the purposes of this suit, since the charge was not filed until almost three weeks after the alleged adverse action of not being hired for the Product Manager position. As there was no evidence before the court of any protected activity by the employee, much less any connection between said activity and an adverse action by the employer, the employee failed to set forth a prima facie case for retaliation. The employer’s enforcement of its application deadline was a legitimate, nonretaliatory reason for the adverse action, said the court, and the employee could not meet his burden to show pretext for retaliation. Thus, the employer was also entitled to summary judgment on the retaliation claim.
The case is No. 3:24-cv-207.
Judge: Rice, W.
Attorneys: David Michael Duwel (David M. Duwel & Associates) for Jeffrey Moore. Douglas Scott Jenks (Auman, Mahan & Furry) for Dayton Lamina Corp.
Companies: Dayton Lamina Corp.
Cases: AgeDiscrimination Discrimination Retaliation OhioNews