Labor & Employment Law Daily Wrap Up, DISCRIMINATION—AGE—E.D. Wis.: Employer’s proffered reason for terminating older surgeon may have been pretext for age discrimination, (Mar 27, 2026)
Law Firms Mentioned:Alan C Olson & Associates | Littler Mendelson
Organizations Mentioned:Ascension Medical Group-Southeast Wisconsin Inc. | Littler Mendelson, PC
By Molly Platnick
The court found downsizing and low productivity may not have been the hospital organization’s honest reason for dismissing the older employee.
A federal district court in Wisconsin denied a hospital employment organization’s motion for summary judgment in a case brought by a former surgeon who alleged he was fired because of his age in violation of the ADEA. The court was satisfied the organization’s need to downsize following the COVID-19 pandemic and the surgeon’s low productivity were legitimate, nondiscriminatory reasons for terminating him but the surgeon successfully argued the nondiscriminatory reasons were a pretext because the organization did not address his productivity before his termination (Battista v. Ascension Medical Group, No. 25-CV-91 (E.D. Wis. Mar. 23, 2026)).
Ascension Medical Group employs medical providers at hospitals in southern Milwaukee. It hired the surgeon under an agreement providing that after 10 years, his annual compensation would be set by the organization’s standard Physician Compensation Plan. The compensation plan relies on work relative value units (wRVUs), a common metric used to assess and compare surgeons’ productivity based on how many surgeries they perform. Ascension rewarded doctors’ productivity with either wRVU credits or a stipend.
Economic recovery plan. Ascension commenced an “economic recovery plan” in spring 2022 to respond to financial hardships caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. It calculated the wRVUs of the three surgeons at the relevant hospital, plus a new hire’s projected wRVUs in his first year. The data suggested the organization could only afford to employ three surgeons at the hospital.
The plaintiff had the lowest wRVUs at his hospital and implied he was planning to retire soon. He told Ascension he would “turn everything over” after mentoring the new hire and stepped down as physician director because he was “planning for the future.” In August 2022, however, the surgeon stated he did not intend to retire. The organization sent a 120-day notice of termination on December 9, 2022, and the surgeon’s last day was April 8, 2023.
The surgeon was 68 years old when his employment was terminated. The organization dismissed a surgeon at another hospital who was 48 years old and had the lowest wRVUs amongst his colleagues. It retained older employees, including a 75-year-old surgeon.
Proffered reason. Ascension argued that following the economic recovery plan was a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for terminating the surgeon. It provided evidence of how and why it conducted the economic recovery plan and the record supported the hospital’s contention it could only afford to employ three surgeons. The data also showed, based on his wRVUs, that the plaintiff was the least productive surgeon at the hospital. The court was persuaded this evidence was a “clear and reasonably specific” explanation for terminating the surgeon that was not based on his age.
Pretext. As to evidence of pretext, the surgeon argued his wRVUs were lower than his colleagues’ because the organization asked him to help “rebuild” the surgical practice at another hospital. The record showed he spent two weeks per month at the other hospital, while one of the other surgeons took over some of his regular shifts. His wRVUs dropped significantly when he started working at the second hospital.
Even at this lower rate, the surgeon always met his contracted hours and was never asked to increase them. In 2022, when he volunteered to take on more hours, he was “told not to worry about it.” The organization had never complained about the surgeon’s wRVUs before his termination and when he first asked for a reason for his dismissal, he was told “it had been decided.” The court found, based on this evidence, a rational factfinder could conclude the low wRVUs were not the organization’s true reason for dismissing the surgeon. Accordingly, the court denied summary judgment on this claim.
The case is No. 2:25-cv-00091-WED.
Judge: Dufflin, W.
Attorneys: Alan C. Olson (Alan C Olson & Associates) for Joseph Battista. Casey M. Kaiser (Littler Mendelson) for Ascension Medical Group-Southeast Wisconsin Inc.
Companies: Ascension Medical Group-Southeast Wisconsin Inc.
Cases: AgeDiscrimination Discrimination Discharge WisconsinNews