Employment Practices Decisions Archive: 1937 - 1995, EMPLOYMENT-PRACTICES 1 EPD ¶9646, Sam H. Clark, et al., Plaintiffs v. Norfolk and Western Railway Company, et al., Defendants., (Feb. 01, 1956), (Feb. 1, 1956)
Sam H. Clark, et al., Plaintiffs v. Norfolk and Western Railway Company, et al., Defendants.
United States District Court, Western District of Virginia, at Roanoke.Civil No. 689, February 1, 1956
Railway Labor Act
Injunctions--Racial Discrimination--Collective Bargaining Agreements.
--In a class suit alleging discrimination on account of race, a railroad and a union representative were enjoined from enforcing a bargaining contract which prevented Negro yardmen, who were excluded from union membership, from qualifying for promotion to car retarder operators, or otherwise denying them such opportunity for advancement upon the same terms and conditions as were afforded other employees. Union representative was further enjoyed from using its position as collective bargaining representative to restrict such advancements.
Joseph C. Waddy, Washington, D. C., George P. Lawrence, Roanoke, Virginia, William C. Gardner and William B. Bryant, Washington, D. C., for Plaintiffs.
S. King Funkhouser and W. P. Hazlegrove, Hazlegrove, Shackelford and Carr, Roanoke, Virginia, for Norfolk and Western Railway Company.
John L. Walker, Woods, Rogers, Muse and Walker, Roanoke, Virginia, and Wayland K. Sullivan, Cleveland, Ohio, for Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen.
PAUL, D. J.: This cause came on to be heard on the thirtieth day of January, 1956, upon the complaint and answers filed herein and the Court, having heard the testimony and the arguments of counsel, and being fully advised in the premises, makes the following
Findings of Fact
1. Plaintiffs are Negro yardmen employed by the Norfolk and Western Railway Company as yard brakemen, and are members of the craft or class of yardmen employed by said railroad company. The seniority of the named plaintiffs is as follows: Sam H. Clark, from June 10, 1913; Robert Coles, from December 3, 1917; Robert A. Hamlar, from June 7, 1920.
2. This is a class action brought by plaintiffs in their individual capacities and as representatives of all the Negro yardmen employed by the Norfolk and Western Railway Company.
3. The Norfolk and Western Railway Company is a corporation engaged in interstate commerce.
4. The Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen is a national labor union and is the collective bargaining representative under the Railway Labor Act of the craft or class of yardmen employed by the Norfolk and Western Railway.
5. By custom and practice, all Negro yardmen employed by said railway company are known as “nonpromotable” yardmen; white yardmen are known as “promotable” yardmen.
6. That during December, 1941 the Norfolk and Western Railway established car retarders in its terminal at Roanoke, Virginia.
7. On December 30, 1941, an agreement was entered into between the Norfolk and Western Railway Company and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen extending the seniority of “promotable” yardmen at Roanoke to include positions of car retarder operators. On March 15, 1952 an agreement was entered into between the Norfolk and Western and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen extending the seniority of “promotable” yardmen at Norfolk, Virginia, to include positions of car retarder operators. On April 7, 1954, subsequent to the filing of this suit, an agreement was made effective between the Norfolk and Western and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen extending the seniority of “promotable” yardmen at Bluefield, West Virginia, to cover positions of car retarder operators. The effect of these agreements was to exclude Negro yardmen from qualifying for, and being assigned to, the position of car retarder operator.
8. Negro yardmen employed by the Norfolk and Western Railway Company are excluded from membership in the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen.
9. The Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen gave the Negro members of the craft or class no notice or opportunity to be heard concerning the making of any of the agreements hereinbefore referred to.
10. As a result of said agreements, plaintiffs and the other members of their class have been denied the opportunity to qualify for, and to be assigned positions as car retarder operators.
11. On September 8, 1954, after this suit was filed, the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen and the Norfolk and Western Railway Company amended the collective bargaining agreement in effect between the parties to remove therefrom the word “promotable” as it applied to the craft or class of yardmen. On November 21, 1955, the Norfolk and Western Railway Company issued permits to members of the craft or class of yardmen, including the Negro members of the craft, authorizing them to attempt to qualify for positions of car retarder operator. Although some Negro yardmen have been given some instructions in the operation of the car retarders, the evidence shows that they have not been given the opportunity to actually operate any of said retarders. No Negro yardmen have been qualified for, or assigned to, positions of car retarder operator.
12. Although the term “promotable” was removed from said collective bargaining agreement under date of September 8, 1954, the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen still excludes Negroes from membership therein and there has been no change in its policy with respect to giving to the Negroes who are excluded notice and opportunity to be heard concerning any matters covering the collective bargaining agreement.
13. The agreements of December 30, 1941, March 15, 1952, and April 7, 1954, were unfair and discriminatory against the plaintiffs and their class.
14. That the evidence adduced at the trial hereof convinces the Court that plaintiffs and their class are still being discriminated against and there is likelihood of continued discrimination against them.
The Court therefore makes the following
Conclusions of Law
1. The Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen, as the collective bargaining representative under the Railway Labor Act of the craft or class of yardmen employed by the Norfolk and Western Railway Company, owes a statutory fiduciary duty to all members of the craft or class of yardmen to represent them fairly and impartially and without hostile discrimination, and is required by the Railway Labor Act to refrain from using its statutory position to discriminate against plaintiffs and their class.
2. That in the making and the enforcement of the agreements referred to in the findings of fact and in the course of its representation of the craft or class of yardmen on the Norfolk and Western Railway, the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen has unlawfully discriminated against plaintiffs and the members of their class because of their race.
3. That the Norfolk and Western Railway Company is precluded by the Railway Labor Act from enforcing or taking the benefits of the unlawful agreements entered into with said Brotherhood.
4. That the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen is under a continuing duty to represent plaintiffs and their class fairly and impartially and said plaintiffs and their class are entitled to injunctive relief to secure said fair representation in the future.
Order for Injunction
Upon Consideration of the evidence adduced at the trial hereof, the admissions of the parties and the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law filed herein it is by the Court this 1st day of February, 1956,
ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED:
1. That the defendant, Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen, its officers, agents, employees, local and general chairmen, and all persons in active concert or participation with it or them, and the defendant, Norfolk & Western Railway Company, its officers, agents, employees, and all persons in active concert or participation with it or them, are hereby permanently restrained and enjoined from denying to plaintiffs and the other Negro members of the craft or class of yardmen employed by the Norfolk & Western Railway Company the right and opportunity to qualify for positions of car retarder operators upon the same terms and conditions as are afforded white members of said craft or class, and, upon qualifying, to be assigned to positions as car retarder operators upon the same terms and conditions as are afforded white members of said craft or class.
2. That the defendant, Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen, its officers, agents, employees, local and general chairmen, and all persons in active concert or participation with it or them, and the defendant, Norfolk & Western Railway Company, its officers, agents, employees and all persons in active concert or participation with it or them, are hereby permanently restrained and enjoined from making and enforcing any collective bargaining agreement, and from carrying on any practices under such agreements, insofar as such agreements and practices either exclude plaintiffs or members of their class from promotion or from qualifying for or being assigned to positions as car retarder operators or otherwise discriminate against Negro yardmen in their qualification for or promotion to the position of car retarder operators on the Norfolk & Western Railway Company.
3. That the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen is hereby restrained and enjoined from using its position as collective bargaining representative under the Railway Labor Act to block, impede or restrict the promotion and advancement of plaintiffs and their class similarly situated on the ground of race.